Why returns build loyalty

Hey there 🧠

Ready for another day of staying ahead of the competition in the Growth race?

Oh and before we go ahead! If your friend sent this to you, be sure to subscribe here! So you don’t miss out on any editions.

Partnership with Shipfusion

Your Checkout Isn’t the Problem. Fulfillment Is.

You can have great ads, a clean PDP, and a perfect checkout. And still lose the customer the moment the order is placed.

Shipfusion placed five real orders across leading clear protein brands within the same hour and tracked every step after purchase. Same cart moment. Completely different delivery realities. That inconsistency is where loyalty breaks quietly.

Here’s what the audit exposed:

• Only 1 brand offered subscriptions in both cart and checkout, even in a habit-driven category
• 80% showed star ratings on PDPs, then removed social proof at checkout
• Only 2 brands upgraded tracking beyond Shopify defaults
• 50% of shipping labels didn’t show the brand name

This is the churn layer you can’t fix with better creative.

Clear protein was just the test case. If you ship products to customers, this report is for you, showing exactly how your brand compares with benchmarks you can act on immediately.

Download the DTC Delivery Files and benchmark your post-checkout reality!

💡 Why Letting Customers Keep Returns Can Increase Loyalty And Sales
Insights from sciencesays

Your order arrives damaged. You expect friction. Instead, the brand refunds you instantly and tells you to keep or donate the item.

That small moment changes everything.

Science now backs what great customer experience teams have quietly learned. Letting customers keep low value items they want to return can significantly boost loyalty, future purchases, and positive word of mouth.

1️⃣ Why Returnless Returns Work: Instant refunds paired with returnless policies remove effort at the worst possible moment in the customer journey. Research shows customers consistently like brands more when they are allowed to keep unwanted items instead of shipping them back. Satisfaction rises, repeat purchase intent increases, and reviews turn more positive when friction disappears.

2️⃣ The Numbers Behind The Effect: Across nine experiments, returnless returns outperformed traditional policies. Brands saw higher ratings for incorrect or defective products, up to thirty percent more positive reviews, stronger word of mouth, higher perceived value, and warmer brand perceptions compared to standard return and replacement flows.

3️⃣ How Framing Strengthens The Impact: The effect intensifies when returnless refunds are framed as a convenience or environmental decision. Encouraging customers to donate unwanted items further boosts goodwill. Asking for proof of damage weakens the effect, reducing positive sentiment and brand warmth.

4️⃣ The Psychology Driving Loyalty: We judge brands the same way we judge people, based on warmth and competence. When a brand gives without expecting anything in return, customers perceive a communal relationship rather than a transactional one. That sense of warmth directly improves trust, loyalty, and overall brand perception.

5️⃣ Practical Recommendations: Allow customers to keep low to moderately priced items while issuing full refunds. Avoid asking for proof. Frame the decision around saving time or reducing unnecessary shipping. Encourage donation instead of disposal. Use the refund moment to surface thoughtful cross sell options aligned with the refund value.

6️⃣ Real Life Example:

Atlas Stationers allows returns within thirty days but requires customers to ship back even inexpensive items like erasers or pencils, with return shipping deducted from refunds. A more customer friendly approach would allow customers to keep items below a price threshold, absorb return shipping costs, and frame the policy as an environmental or community focused choice. Encouraging donations to schools or libraries would further amplify goodwill while reducing operational friction.

The Takeaway

Returns do not have to be a loss. When handled generously, they become a trust building moment. Letting customers keep low value items while refunding them transforms disappointment into loyalty, advocacy, and repeat purchases. Sometimes, the smartest retention strategy is generosity.

💡 How To Build An App Using Claude Artifacts

Building small tools usually means wireframes, specs, and handoffs. Claude Artifacts compress that entire process into a single conversation.

Instead of coding first, you describe the problem. Claude handles the rest.

1️⃣ Start Inside Claude Artifacts: Open Claude and click Artifacts from the sidebar. Select New Artifact and choose Apps and websites. This opens a workspace designed specifically for building functional tools, not just generating text.

2️⃣ Describe The Problem In Plain Language: Explain what you want to build and why, without worrying about technical detail. For example, you might ask Claude to create a simple app that helps sales reps qualify leads faster by scoring them and suggesting next actions. Clarity of intent matters more than precision here.

3️⃣ Let Claude Ask Clarifying Questions: Claude will automatically ask follow up questions about your audience, goals, inputs, and constraints. This step replaces long requirement documents and ensures the artifact matches real use cases.

4️⃣ Generate The Artifact: Based on the conversation, Claude builds the app within minutes. What you get is not a mockup, but a usable artifact you can interact with immediately.

5️⃣ Refine And Expand As Needed: Once generated, you can edit, extend, or iterate on the artifact directly. The tool evolves as your needs change, without starting from scratch.

The Takeaway

Claude Artifacts turn problem descriptions into working apps. By shifting from specs to conversation, they make building internal tools faster, simpler, and far more accessible to non technical teams.

As we prepare more "Growthful" content, we'd love to hear your thoughts on today's edition! Feel free to share this with someone who would appreciate it. 🥰